Starvation Study #1 - July 2005
For the past months I've been frantically studying nutrition and everything
around it (physiology, biology and basic biochemistry). This has lead me into
purchasing a simple "whole-blood" glucose meter - an electronic device
for about $15 (mind you, the sticks that you use for testing are the one's that
really cost). The device is not 100% accurate, the results can differ as much
as 20% from professional laboratory instruments, so keep that in mind when you
look at the charts below!
With this device in my hand and a package of ketone urine test sticks
(Ketostix) I embarked on a personal "scientific study" of starvation. The
whole idea of this long-term project is to record blood glucose levels when
starving under different circumstances; e.g. autumn/winter/spring/summer
simulated survival weekends, semi-starvation (living on meager rations for at
least several days), etc.
Starving is a piece of cake
I have starved for 24h or more on several occasions but I have never
before had the opportunity to actually follow what happens in the body, so this
experiment was truly exciting. Previous experiences of starvation or
semi-starvation has given me a very high threshold for mentally coping with
hunger and it is my opinion that the feeling of hunger is all mental. If you
know exactly what stages you are going to pass through on your way, starving is
a piece of cake (no, wait... maybe not cake, not pizza either, or pancakes...
wait... damn, I'm hungry ;)
Once the hunger has been conquered the next obstacle will follow - migraine
headache - mainly caused by lack of serotonin (a neurotransmitter, or
"chemical filter substance") in the brain. Serotonin is
synthesized from Tryptophan, an essential amino acid which we get from a
wide variety of foods (nuts, bananas, fish, meat, milk, etc.). The medical
literature I've read doesn't seem to know exactly what causes
"starvation headache", but one thing is clear - not everyone starving
seem to suffer from it and low levels of serotonin has a lot to do with
headaches in general. After about a day the headache ought to be gone and at
this point the body has adapted to the new condition - starvation - in which the
body will (continue) resorting to breaking down fat reserves into energy. You
eventually smell a slightly fruity, acetone-like smell in your breath. This is
due to build-up of so-called ketone bodies (or rather beta-hydroxybutyrate,
acetoacetate and acetone, the latter is expelled via the lungs) in your body.
Although I have not gone without food for more than about 48 hours, I have on
several occasions experienced that when the headache is gone everything starts
to feel really good - read all about it under Digging
deeper below.
The experiment
In Starvation Study #1 I was going to hike at least 40km without food for 24
hours, but I had to work overtime on Saturday so I (naturally) took my
experiment with me to work so to speak (I starved there for a few hours
instead).
Working and starving was a perfect match, no problem walking fast through the
city despite of that I hadn't eaten since Friday evening (rest is really all you
need after air & water and I got plenty that night). I took 1 blood sample test
every 2 hours.
Back home I drank water, took a Ketostix test, put on my backpack and went out
for a short walk. On my way back I hiked a little faster - I really felt that I
was going slightly above the bar, I literally felt my blood glucose level sink,
which the glucose test later on proved.
Later, at 19:15, I ate a biscuit chocolate bar and an "almond bun"
(mandelkubb in swedish). I immediatly started to take 1 sample each 10 minutes
in order to record what happened and the result was very interesting. It took
approximately 10-15 minutes for the blood glucose value to start to change,
certainly due to digestion of sugar. I didn't eat anything more until about
24:00, which is when the blood glucose had got back to it's preprandial levels
(the levels before meal).
The result
The result was pretty much what I had expected and learned from different sources,
especially this site and
this page.
The blood glucose level was nearly normal the entire time caused by
well-balanced gluconeogenesis. Hiking home a litte fast showed up as a small
depression and a slightly un-balanced curve, which was interesting. Just before
going out on that walk I started having the characteristic headache which passed
after a couple of hours. The Ketostix showed pink, then dark pink a few hours
later (despite that my urine color was normal).
Detailed curve when eating snacks
The Ketostix result was obviously approximate and may have been completely
different if tested with proper equipment. Below you'll find a few pictures of
the tests conducted. Click on an image for a larger version.
Digging deeper...
Please keep in mind - I am not a biologist, I may have gotten some of this
stuff wrong so don't take it for the ultimate truth (please e-mail me if you
know I'm wrong somewhere, thank you!)
Ketone bodies are created when the mitochondria of a liver cell receives too
much acetyl-CoA as a result of breakdown of fatty acids. The excessive
acetyl-CoA is converted to acetoacetate, beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetone (all 3
commonly called ketone bodies). Ketone bodies can be used as fuel by the cells
in the brain (up to 50-60% after about 2 weeks of starvation, some areas of the
brain still require glucose so it can't shift to ketones completely), the heart
and other tissues. In these cells the ketone bodies - except acetone - are
converted back into acetyl-CoA and used as energy. However, the red blood cells
are completely dependent on glucose and in addition, the brain still need about
50% glucose to function. After about 12 hours of starvation all glucose stores
are basically empty (the liver and, to a lesser extent, the muscles store
glucose in the form of glycogen). Since many organs are dependent on glucose it
has to be re-generated in some way. This process is called gluconeogenesis.
In an attempt not to create too much confusion: A cell's mitochondria (the
body's power plants) has something called the TriCarboxylic Acid cycle (TCA cycle)
AKA citric acid cycle or Kreb's cycle which is responsible for both anabolism
(build-up, storage) and catabolism (breakdown). When glucose is plentiful
it will be converted to pyruvate, then converted to acetyl-CoA which enters
the TCA cycle via oxaloacetate and eventually produces ATP - Adenosine
TriPhosphate - a substance able to store and transport energy within cells. ATP
is crucial for us to live so the TCA cycle and ATP production never stops, but
slows down during rest or starvation.
Gluconeogenesis
During gluconeogenesis a non-carbohydrate source is first converted into
pyruvate, then into oxaloacetate, then into phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP), then into
glucose, then out in the blood system to maintain a stable blood sugar level.
Fat is naturally used as energy here, but can not be used for gluconeogenesis as
it goes into fatty acids then directly into acetyl-CoA. Humans and animals can
not convert acetyl-CoA to pyruvate which is required in order to generate
oxaloacetate for gluconeogenesis, instead the acetyl-CoA is used directly as
energy (it enters the TCA cycle and yields ATP). So, the non-carbohydrate source
is mainly protein, i.e. muscles are being broken down into pyruvate in order to
create glucose. First, amino acids from protein in skeletal muscles are used. It
is entirely possible to lose all muscles before losing fat, it all depends on
one's fat/muscle ratio.
Since oxaloacetate is being used for gluconeogenesis, it's quite "busy"
and doesn't have enough time to deal with all the massive amounts of acetyl-CoA
released from breakdown of fatty acids. When there's not enough oxaloacetate to
deal with the acetyl-CoA of fatty acids it's commonly called incomplete fat
breakdown. The acetyl-CoA won't wait, but will instead be converted into
ketone bodies, namely acetoacetate, beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetone. Various
muscles (most importantly the heart) and the central nervous system can use
these ketone bodies as fuel during long-time starvation - all part of the body's
impressive survival system designed to use fat and reduce the usage of important
glucose. A healthy person (non-diabetic) will be in a state called ketosis (not
harmful) for many weeks before eventually dying of heart failure (the last
protein source in the body that is used for gluconeogenesis). A diabetic will
get ketoacidosis and eventually die from that (whenever the ketone level in the
blood goes passed 10 mmol/L).
Michel Blomgren
Survival enthusiast
michel.blomgren tigerteam.se
|